Okay, it’s not a Monday, but y’all know what that means.
The newest Marvel movie has been unleashed to the masses. So far it’s taken a big hit from the critics, and from some comic book nerds as well. But what about us average folk who just like watching the MCU movies and have no ulterior agendas (in that we dont get paid to watch stuff) or pre conceived notions about how the characters or storylines are supposed to go? Well, that’s what I’m here for. the everyday fan’s perspective.
Regular readers take note: normally daughter Tessa would join me for these reviews, but we weren’t able to see this one together. Never fear though, Tessa fans, She will see it tonight and I’ll let her post something on the blog later on. That’s why this is part one of the review, because it’s just my thoughts and you’ll get her POV on it all tonight or tomorrow. Anyway, let’s get to it.
Captain America: Brave New World is the first film to feature Sam Wilson as the Cap, and is somewhat of a continuation of the Marvel TV Series Falcon and the Winter Soldier. It is also a sequel to Endgame and to a lesser extent, Eternals. What it really is though, is a sequel to The Incredible Hulk.
As the movie begins, Lieutenant General and former Secretary of State Thaddeus Ross has just been elected the President of the United States, and Sam has well and truly taken over as Captain America. Though their relationship has been adversarial in the past (what with the Sokovia accords and all) both men realize they need to make an uneasy alliance and work together for the good of the country. An assignation attempt is made on Ross, sending Sam into a story that involves conspiracy, misinformation, the threat of international war, and Red Hulk smashing his way into the picture. So, you know, standard Marvel stuff.
This film isn’t so much a super hero movie as a political action thriller. I mean, sure, lots of stuff goes “boom” and there’s some major feats of derring-do, but the action takes a backseat to the story itself. Which in this case is both good and bad. Honestly, the story is a little thin in places, and some characters and aspects could have been delved into more. There are multiple interesting aspects, both from the political and moral issues raised and from character development standpoints, that are mentioned but glossed over-even for a Marvel movie. That’s a bit of a misstep, but it’s okay because the movie is still entertaining enough to keep the interest level up.
As for the action scenes…they’re fine. There’s not much we haven’t seen before, but again, that’s okay. While none of the action really brought me to the edge of my seat, it was all done perfectly well. It’s just that in this day and age audiences have seen big action scenes a billion times and they all tend to get a little same-y after a while. So while there was nothing particularly wrong with the action in this movie it didn’t knock me off my feet either. So I’m not sure if it’s the film itself, or just me on this one.
Well, that is, until Red Hulk shows up anyway. Those scenes alone were worth the price of admission, but Red’s screen time is regrettably short.
It was kind of nice, though, to have a Marvel film rooted firmly on Earth and in our reality for a change. The MCU has been so into the Multiverse for the last four or five years that the films were getting a little crazy. I actually liked some of those movies, but most of them were pretty spotty. Captain America Brave New World provides a nice soft reset for the MCU by giving us a movie that is more grounded than anything we’ve seen for a while and actually kind of feels like a phase one or phase two MCU film. It’s far from a perfect, sure, but it might just be what Marvel needs right now.
Okay, let’s talk performances. Anthony Mackie (Cap) is a big onscreen presence and an effortlessly cool guy, which makes him a treat to watch. The only downside is that Mackie has too much swagger ,just as a human being, that it almost makes the more emotional scenes difficult to buy into for me. I’m not saying he can’t act-he certainly can, I just don’t relate when he’s playing the softer scenes. That one is just me. Other cast members are exceptional too. Carl Lumbly elevates the character of Isaiah (a holdover form the TV series) well beyond the scripted work. Tim Blake Nelson is reliably good (if you remember his character from back in phase one you know where this movie is going) but both he and his character are underused. This is Marvel we’re talking about here, though, so he could always come back. Again.
Harrison Ford absolutely steals the show, because of course he does. Ford takes over the role of Ross from the late, great William Hurt, which is kind of a shame, really. You see, this movie is just as much about Ross as it is Captain America. Arguably more so. It would have been cool to see what Hurt would have done with this script, and to see him get a big payoff on screen for what he’s done in the franchise. Be that as it may, Harrison Ford does a superb job in the role. He’s not just cashing a check here, or appearing in the MCU because it’s the thing to do, he gives an actual performance and the movie is all the better for it.
Okay, so what’s the verdict overall?
I think this movie is flawed, but fun. The pace is a little slower than what we are used to with other Marvel movies, and the whole “undercutting drama with bad jokes” Marvel movie trademark is kept to a minimum, which is kind of an unexpected change but a refreshing one. It could have been a touch more exciting, and could have gone deeper, but there’s plenty to like about what’s there. Also the cameos are cool but I won’t spoil them. It’s a little clunky, but it also feels familiar and is a solid, but not mind blowing entry into the MCU canon.
As a sequel, a connector of story lines, and a touchstone for future projects I’d say Captain America: Brave New World works well. As far as standing on its own two feet, well, it’s a little wobbly but at the end of the day it still stands.
I give it a 3 1/2 out of 5.
That’s it for now. See you soon with Tessa’s take, and back again later for more MonDaves!
P.S.-The after credit scene isn’t really worth it. It’s fine but not all that cool or revelatory.
P.P.S.-On a side note, why do we need the character of Joaquin Ramirez? If Sam still has his Falcon style wings, why do we need Falcon Jr.? It bugged me in the series and it bugs me now. That alone (and, sorry/not sorry, Danny Ramirez’s bland portrayal) kept this movie away from the 4 star rating. I was trying not to go there but here we are.